Oracle

Sorcery 

Choose an opponent. You and that player each sacrifice a creature. Each player who sacrificed a creature this way draws two cards.
Choose an opponent. Return a creature card from your graveyard to the battlefield, then that player returns a creature card from their graveyard to the battlefield.

Tournooi-info

Legal in: Vintage, Legacy, Commander

Officiele rulings

2014-11-07 - wotc
The sacrifice isn't optional. If you control at least one creature, you must sacrifice one. If you control no creatures, you won't sacrifice one and you won't draw two cards. The same is true for the chosen opponent.

2014-11-07 - wotc
You choose which creature card you're returning to the battlefield, then the chosen opponent chooses which creature card they are returning. These choices aren't made until Infernal Offering resolves. Neither card is a target of Infernal Offering.

2014-11-07 - wotc
You may choose the same opponent for each of the effects, or you may choose different opponents. None of the affected players are targets of the spell.

2014-11-07 - wotc
You choose the opponents for each effect as the spell resolves.

Decktips